Thursday, July 26, 2012

EDWM Deputies to the General Convention Speak Out

Guest Blogger: Karmel Puzzuoli, Communications Assistant to the Bishop

Two years ago, the 136th convention of the Episcopal Diocese of Western Michigan elected its clergy and lay deputies to represent us at the 77th General Convention (GC) in Indianapolis earlier this month. In conversation or written reflection, our EDWM deputation was able to report their impressions, reflections and experiences.

If you read Bishop Gepert’s Weekly Teaching last week, he remarked on the high level of civility at the GC compared with previous years. Our EDWM deputies had the same sentiment. Anne Davidson (St. Mark’s Coldwater), said, “Even though [in the House of Deputies] we didn’t agree on everything, it was certainly possible to work together and respect each other’s beliefs and opinions.”

Such was true even during one of the most contentious moments of the convention. After the vote to provide liturgical resources for same-sex blessings, as well as to disallow discrimination against transgendered people, the Bishop of South Carolina and most of his deputation who were against these changes left the GC, a controversy that continues to this day.

“We were sitting next to the South Carolinians,” said Musette El Mohammed, St. Martin of Tours, Kalamazoo. “It was amazing to watch those conversations while they were happening on the floor of the House of Deputies. I loved the way they engaged in the debate even though they knew they were not on the winning side. No one booed or hissed when the conservative dioceses spoke. They were respected even though their concerns were not addressed.”

Rev. Laurel Dahill, rector of St. Andrew’s Grand Rapids, echoes those sentiments: “People had some real concerns and everybody had a chance to be heard at a profoundly respectful level.” Rev. Dahill added that her own congregation has a same-sex blessing coming up in a few months and plans to make use of the liturgy approved.

One of the most significant resolutions passed was C095 which calls for creation of a task force to re-imagine the workings of the Episcopal Church in the 21st century. It sailed unanimously through the House of Deputies and the House of Bishops the following day. It creates a special task force of up to 24 people who will gather ideas in the next two years from all levels of the church about possible reforms to its structures, governance and administration. Their work will culminate in a special gathering of people from every diocese to hear what recommendations the task force plans to make to the 78th General Convention. Its final report is due by November 2014.

“There’s a lot to suggest that the Episcopal Church is doing things in an outdated model,” said Bill Fleener (St. David’s Lansing). “Some of the hierarchy is kind of leftover from a different era, financially and systems-wise, so I think we took a positive step to allow structures of the church to change.”

Musette echoed the sentiments of Bishop Gepert with respect to our direction as a people of faith: “I think that our whole focus on mission [in our diocese] has been on target with what the national church has been saying. We have really focused on outreach rather than in-reach. We’re also on target in our understanding of inclusion. I think our diocese has been a standout in that area.”

The attendees of the GC found the worship services to be inspiring, diverse and filled with the Holy Spirit. They experienced steel drums playing “How Great Thou Art,” spontaneous dancing, a great mix of celebrants, preachers and readings in a variety of languages.

One of the most moving experiences that deputies have at the GC is the democratic process that governs the Episcopal Church through its House of Deputies and House of Bishops. Both laity and clergy have a significant say in the direction of the church. “Unlike nearly every other religious institution in the world, we sit down and decide where we go in the future,” said Bill Fleener.

The work of a deputy at the GC is intense, with sessions beginning as early as 7:30 a.m. and going as late at 10:00 p.m.

“One of many highlights for me was working on the Certification of Minutes Committee,” said Pam Chapman (St. Philip’s, Grand Rapids). “It allowed me to re-live the legislation of the day before which enabled me to be more prepared for the upcoming day’s business. The committee met each morning at 7:30 a.m. to review and correct, if necessary, the minutes before reporting to the House of Deputies that the minutes have been reviewed and certified them to be correct, daily.”

The EDWM deputation recommended that anyone who is elected deputy needs to start educating themselves immediately after their election, which will be at the diocesan convention in 2013, so that they can hit the ground running at the 78th General Convention.

Overall, the deputies enjoyed spending time with people from around the country, but also getting to know people from our diocese better.

“I enjoyed time spent with people talking about what best ways forward in all categories of church life,” said Rev. Jennifer Adams, rector of Grace Church, Holland. “I was very aware of our courage as a church and also our limitations. We are hard-working and so very human. I watched us stretch ourselves forward and bump into our limitations! And so, we need to meet again in three years. Our work is not done!”

More comments from EDWM Deputies:
“As a history teacher, I would love to have had students see how a bicameral organization works. Seeing that certain resolutions in the House of Bishops or the House of Deputies was impressive. Both houses had an opportunity to discuss,  change , or clarify, very much like our governmental legislature does.” – Musette El Mohammed

“The worship services make being at convention an experience that all Episcopalians should have the opportunity to take part in. Each morning there was a different preacher of the sermon. I was able to take what was shared with us, by the preacher, to the legislative sessions of the convention. I was able to worship with my friend Alice Webley Harris (formerly of our diocese) each morning. It was a pleasure to know we would share the peace with her at the first of each day.” – Pam Chapman

“I feel as if the Open Communion conversation is one that needs to happen with as much intention as we have approached other topics, but there just wasn’t room for that breadth of conversation this time.  I think a people gathered can only do so much in the time that is Convention, especially when everything takes genuinely faithful attention, prayer and thought… I am always struck by the breadth of voices that are our church, the sincere faith behind the work that’s done, the quantity of work that is done, and the process by which decisions are made by the whole Body (or at least reps of it.) I find the process itself quite moving in terms of what it proclaims theologically and I’m always very grateful to be part of it.”
– Rev. Jen Adams

“I was frustrated that there was so MUCH legislation (nearly 400 resolutions), and with the shortened schedule (8 days instead of 10) it was hard to keep up with all of the resolutions and amendments, but given all of that, I felt very honored to be able to represent the Diocese, and listen to the Holy Spirit and the deliberations, and then vote my conscience.” – Anne Davidson

“The spirit was definitely there. I was moved
when we voted unanimously on a restructuring resolution. To have 850 people in agreement created a hush in the room, and showed us that the spirit is really working through us. God found a way to break in.”
– Rev. Laurel Dahill

Deputies in GC Attendance
Clergy
The Rev. Jennifer Adams,
    Grace Episcopal Church, Holland, MI
The Rev. Canon William Spaid,
    Episcopal Diocese of Western Michigan
The Rev. Laurel Dahill,
    St. Andrews Episcopal Church, Big Rapids
The Rev. Gregory Brown,
    Emmanuel, Petoskey, MI
The Rev. Mary Perrin, St. Martin of Tours, Kalamazoo, MI
    attended as an alternate

Lay
William Fleener, Jr., St. David’s, Lansing, MI
Musette El Mohammed, St. Martin of Tours, Kalamazoo, MI
Anne Davidson, St. Mark’s, Coldwater, MI
Pam Chapman, St. Philip’s, Grand Rapids
Tom Perrin, St. Martin of Tours, Kalamazoo, MI
    attended as an alternate

Thursday, July 19, 2012

On the 77th General Convention and Bishop's Sabbatical


On the 77th General Convention of The Episcopal Church
I returned from General Convention last week with the wonderful feeling that it was without a doubt the best one I’ve ever attended.

I credit the positive atmosphere to the leadership of Katharine Jefferts-Schori, who has set a tone of respect in the Church.

Some of you may have heard that during the convention, the Bishop of South Carolina and most of his deputation left after the legislation on resources for same-sex blessings. In past years, that would have created a ruckus, but at this General Convention, his decision was honored. An invitation to stay in relationship was given, but when it was not successful, we moved on and remained healthy.

I was also impressed to see the growing diversity in the church. We were honored to experience our American Indian participants’ music, sign language, dress and readings in Shoshoni.  We also had liturgies in Spanish, showing us the wide variety of expression in the church. There were guests from Africa as well as Sudanese-Americans gathered together to praise God and worship. 

When we gather as a general convention, we get to see a worldwide Anglicanism that we don’t see in our own dioceses and parishes.

The only other thing I want to say about the General Convention is that with regard to the budget, it was created with a consciousness of the poor, and was developed based upon the Five Marks of Mission.

On Sabbatical
My sabbatical is from September-December 2012, and I’m grateful to reflect where I’ve been and where I’m going.

For me, it will be a time to work on a book, which combines my knowledge of Family Systems Theory, practical experience and the Rule of St. Benedict, and will be about how we need to incorporate the radical teachings of Jesus into our lives and institutions. I’ve chosen the ironic title “To Hell With Jesus, We’re Here For the Music,” because I am a strong believer that we need to move beyond having an experience of God in worship. As I’ve related before, experiences of God are not enough. It goes back to the members vs. disciples argument. If we are to change the world, it is by being disciples, not simply members of an institution.

I also hope the time away will be restorative. I will have more opportunity to spend time with our children and grandchildren. I will be spending time meditating on how to make a good transition from my episcopacy to the new bishop you will elect. I want that to happen in the most healthy and productive way that it can.

Further, I would like to add that I will retain ecclesiastical authority during my sabbatical. If there are important decisions to be made, please feel free to contact the staff, and they will relay those important messages to me while I’m away.

Thursday, July 12, 2012

Deacons: A Separate and Complete Order


I spent the last day in June at the Day for the Deacons – our annual deacon retreat in Big Rapids. There were six deacons present. One of the things we talked about was how the deacon’s role in the Church is unique and separate from priestly ministry.

I feel strongly that deacons need to be treated as a separate and complete order. Currently, the Episcopal Church, as part of the priestly ordination process, ordains future priests following their graduation from seminary to the transitional diaconate, but I have always supported direct ordination to the priesthood. 

Deacons are not junior priests, and ordaining future priests to the transitional diaconate only serves to confuse people about the important ministry of true deacons, who are not on their way to priesthood.

The diaconate is also called “The Servanthood.” While we are all called to serve, deacons are called to get the church off its butt and do something to alleviate the plight of the marginalized.

Unlike priests, deacons are not called to represent Christ at the altar or gather community around them. They are clergy, yes, but they are called to be a stone in the shoe of the church, an irritant that won’t go away, that mobilizes the church on behalf of the poor, oppressed, disenfranchised, sick – all of those whose voices are not predominant in our society.

Deacons who focus on their calling are one of the greatest gifts to the Church.

Ellie was a deacon in one of my parishes at the height of the AIDS scare in the 1980s, the time after the disease was discovered but no one knew how it was transmitted. She started a ministry for people dying of AIDS. At the time, those dying people were truly disenfranchised; their families had rejected them, and people were afraid of them, wouldn’t even touch them. Ellie mobilized our church to respond to the great need of being with those who were dying. In the process, she opened up our parish to accept people who were HIV-positive and their kids, some of whom were also HIV-positive.

The impact of Ellie’s work didn’t hit me until one Sunday when a young HIV-positive woman with two HIV-positive children tearfully thanked our congregation for accepting her and her children. When she walked down from the pulpit, the congregation rose and embraced her. It’s one of the most powerful moments I’ve witnessed in the Christian community. The Kingdom of God was present in the moment of that congregational embrace.

This illustrates how deacons have the power to transform the church.

Maybe God is calling you to serve Christ and his church in this way.

Deacons work directly under the authority of the Bishop and are expected to go where needed. People called to stay in their own parishes are not called to be deacons, but instead to active lay ministry, which is also needed and important. Bishops, however, assign deacons to ministry, and deacons willingly go where needed.

If you would like more information about becoming a deacon, contact our Archdeacon, The Venerable Christine Tillman. Her email address is christine.tillman@sbcglobal.net.

Thursday, June 28, 2012

Stuck vs. Unstuck Congregations

I had the good fortune to be a student of Edwin H. Friedman, a rabbi whose work in congregational leadership influenced me almost as much as Jesus (also a rabbi). His books are focused on leaders developing three main areas of themselves: self-differentiation, being non-anxious and being present with those you are leading.

I was reviewing my notes from one of his classes, which have become brown around the edges, and came across something I had transcribed: “A church is stuck when it keeps recycling the same unquestioned answers.”

This really does bear up to my experience working with congregations and clergy across the diocese.
When a church keeps saying the same thing over and over again, rehashing the same issues, it is a “stuck church.”

No amount of thinking, rationalizing or discussing will change that dynamic. The answers to the problems are not found in anyone’s rationale, no matter how well-intentioned.

What can move a congregation forward? How can it become un-stuck?

Adventure.

It’s the kind of adventure that takes the form of a mission or a ministry, helping the congregation move beyond itself. It’s something that everyone can get excited about and focus upon.

For example, in my days as a priest, I heard of a parish once that had been vibrant decades before but had declined to nine families. But when it stumbled across an opportunity to provide an after-school program to middle school kids who had been abused and neglected, it found a revitalizing ministry. Ironically, the parish originally was built with an orphanage attached to it called “The Home for Friendless Girls” (tragically true) that had closed decades before. In stumbling across this new ministry of helping abused, neglected and unwanted kids, the parish happened upon its founding adventure. The parish had energy again. That’s what got them unstuck. What had worked in the parish’s inception worked again.

Peter Steinke asks, in his book Healthy Congregations, some questions worth considering, “How many congregations believe they are in the ‘we exist for ourselves’ business rather than ‘we are in mission to the community, even the world’ business?” He goes on to say in his next book Congregational Leadership in Anxious Times, “Congregations can benefit from their steady flow of positive programs, ministerial acts, and supportive gatherings. People can draw from their positive emotional investments as a resource to move past the pressing moment.”

When a congregation finds its adventure – and it’s not the same for every congregation – then it becomes un-stuck.

How does a congregation find its adventure?

It comes from someone in the congregation who is able to think differently, someone who isn’t drawn into rehashing the same problems over and over.

I’m happy to say that we have many un-stuck congregations in our diocese. They have discovered the importance of adventure in ministry and mission.

They also have a sense of humor. When I observe the behavior in healthy congregations, people are playful with one another. They exhibit an absence of anxiety. It’s a wonderful thing to see because in the presence of anxiety, people get really serious. When people are free to dream, when they are able to focus on matters besides their church’s problems, they are free to have a good time together.

The un-stuck churches in our diocese are soaring. The stuck churches can’t move forward and their mission work in the outside world is very minimal.

Is your community of faith stuck, continually recycling the same old stuff? Or is it soaring, energized by adventure in mission and ministry? The kingdom of God needs high-flyers, able to see beyond themselves. I think both rabbis would agree on that.

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

The Five Marks of Mission


If you subscribe to any of the email lists from The Episcopal Church or The Episcopal News Service, you’ve no doubt come across General Convention information related to the Five Marks of Mission.

For The Episcopal Church, these Five Marks of Mission are a way of acknowledging that the mission of the Church is the same as the mission of Christ; they are the foundational basis for everything we do in our congregations, dioceses and as individuals.

I have a few suggestions for ways that congregations can set themselves up to follow the Five Marks of Mission:

1.      Vision for the mission is required. It means letting go of the constant self-care and building-care that are part of maintenance. You do not see “maintenance” on the Five Marks of Mission. We must be able to envision the mission work in our community and be convicted enough by the Gospel to do it.
2.      Support the vision. Supporting this vision requires some sacrifice from the congregation. In order to move toward the mission, the congregation needs to face sabotage from those who wish to remain in maintenance mode.
3.      Do the work of the mission and put resources toward it. Small committed communities of faith can do this! It requires that we share our resources generously, that we are steadfastly disciples of Christ rather than members of a church.

Archbishop Desmond Tutu and our Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori recently had a conversation on mission in the 21st century that enlightens us to the impact of mission work on the world, and on ourselves spiritually. Our presiding bishop explained how mission work can bring us closer to God. She said, “If we recognized the image of God wherever we go, the world would work very differently, but we live in a society that so often assumes enemy rather than image of God, and the conversation is lost before it begins.”

Archbishop Desmond Tutu’s perspective on mission is clearly personal to him. He explained that if it hadn’t been for missionaries in South Africa during the last century, many of the native people would not have been able to receive an education or medical care. 

“Many of us are alive today because of men and women who built clinics and hospitals. Many of us were educated in missionary schools, and helped to remain healthy in missionary hospitals. We have the capacity to do an enormous amount of good,” he said. “I think if we are smart enough to make atoms that can obliterate us, shouldn’t we be smart enough to be able to feed? It is our privilege and responsibility to help turn this wilderness into the garden that God had always intended for his world to be.”

The Episcopal Church is asking people to take a quiz on their Facebook page regarding the attitudes about mission, as well as submit videos of local ministry in action, which will be voted upon later.
I’d also like to ask parishes how they could use these Five Marks of Mission as a focus for moving from maintenance to mission. These Five Marks really speak to our spending priorities. How are our parishes already using the Five Marks of Mission? These are important questions to ask as we move toward the 77th General Convention.

“Mission is about receiving that love, and then responding,” said the Presiding Bishop. “God comes to us in human flesh to give us the gift to be sent into the world to spread that love. It is a matter of calling the near and far-off together and in one fold.”

Thursday, June 7, 2012

Change vs. Transition


Last week, the staff members of the diocese enjoyed an overnight retreat at The Hermitage in Three Rivers where the Rev. Cindy Nawrocki, who is our diocesan deacon for domestic mission trips and Jubilee Ministries, led us in exercises surrounding the concepts of change and transition.
Since the announcement of my retirement, the staff and many people in the diocese are aware of impending transitions.

In this workshop, Cindy explained that transition can be known as the land of uncertainty, a time between an ending and a beginning. She said “We can use this time to be anxious and worried or we can use this time to grow and learn something new about ourselves.” We were given the opportunity to answer the following questions about ourselves, and then expanded our conversation to the changes that are going to affect all of us:

·        Where were you 10 years ago? (Vocationally, spiritually, physically, emotionally.)
·        Where do you want to be 10 years from now? (Vocationally, spiritually, emotionally.)
·        What have been some of the biggest transitions you have made in your life? Were they made of your own choice? What inner growth came from those times of transition?
·        What were some of the most surprising changes that have happened in your life?

One of the most important things I took away was the distinction between change and transition. Cindy quoted William Bridges: “There can be any number of changes but unless there are transitions, nothing will be different when the dust clears.”

In short, we learned that change is external and transition is internal. One follows the other. 

Sometimes change comes first, but sometimes transition leads us to change. What’s dangerous is when they don’t go together.

There have been occasions during my time as Bishop in which it has been necessary to force changes with the hope that a transition will take place in the hearts and minds of those involved. My hope has been that by doing those difficult things, the Spirit will enter and make things healthier.

But I have found that things get very messy before they get better … and that a mess is a sign that a change/transition is taking place.

Changes and transitions rarely happen smoothly, however, but as Christian people, we trust the Spirit to make things right. As long as we hold onto our own stuff, we can’t receive what the spirit has to offer. In going through changes, we really must allow the Spirit to work to create something healthy.

Recommended reading:
Thirst, by Mary Oliver, Beacon Press
Open the Door: A Journey to the True Self, by Joyce Rupp, Sorin Books
How Can I Let Go if I Don’t Know I’m Holding On?, by Linda Douty, Morehouse Publishing
When the Heart Waits, by Sue Mink Kidd, Harper Collins Publishing
A Time for Leaving, by Mary Fahy, Paulist Press
The Gift of Change, by Marianne Williamson, Harper Collins Publishing
Transitions: Making Sense of Life’s Changes, by William Bridges, Addision-Wesley Publishing
The Language of Letting Go, by Melody Beattie
Growing Wings, by Kristen Jongen   (from Grace Church, Traverse City)

Membership is not enough.


Bishop’s Message

I will freely admit that I’ve never had an original idea. I love it when other people give me a model of language to express something I know inside me.  Most recently, I feel a deep sense of appreciation for Timothy Dombek’s exploration of the dichotomy between Membership and Discipleship in the church.

Those of you who attended our 2012 Diocesan Convention in Traverse City last month will remember Timothy Dombek as the keynote speaker. He is the Canon to the Ordinary for the Diocese of Arizona. He also spoke at Stewardship University which was held in Grand Rapids earlier this month.

While we use the word “member” freely in our parishes, Dombek makes the distinction between those who identify themselves as members and those whose primary focus is to be followers of Jesus, i.e. disciples.

Here are some examples of Dombek’s observations:

The Expectations of a Member:
  • ·        To give money to others to do ministry
  • ·        To pay “dues” to receive services, like a visit from the rector.
  • ·        To fill a slot in the church membership.
Members Assume the following:
  • ·        The mission field is elsewhere, not here.
  • ·        The goal is to get and keep members.
But while the members are focused on the congregation, disciples are focused on following and doing the work of Jesus. Dombek explains that when Jesus is our focal point, “our lives will naturally show forth acts of kindness and generosity and ministry becomes a way of life.”

The Expectations of a Disciple:

  • ·        To do the ministry themselves, offer their resources, discern and deploy their own gifts.
  • ·        To be transformed through worship and faith.
  • ·        To be part of a community.
Disciples assume the following:

  • ·        The mission field is at the door of the church.
  • ·        There are high expectations of disciples, including diligence.
It brings to mind an image about a swimming pool from a sermon I heard once a long time ago.
“All the noise is at the shallow end.”

I have seen my fair share of church fights, and in my experience, they arise from being in the shallow end of the pool. Those who are in the shallow end have time for shallow things; those who move to the more difficult space of the deep water are busy with the work of swimming, or metaphorically, growing in their relationship with Jesus, carrying out his mission, and being transformed by their relationship to him.

Last Saturday, we confirmed, received and reaffirmed the baptismal vows of 64 new disciples. I said in my sermon to them, “Today you are saying you want to move to the deep end of the pool, where life isn’t so secure, where you can’t feel your feet beneath you. The spirit has called you.”

To have an experience of God in worship is most wonderful. But it does not make you a disciple. You need to go deeper into the water.

We need more disciples in the church. Membership in the church is not enough. The disciples came to Jesus with open minds and a willingness to be transformed, as should we.